Before diving into specific models, it's essential to understand what distinguishes a good Submariner homage from a cheap knock-off. A quality homage pays tribute to the original design while maintaining its own identity and offering solid value. Here's a breakdown of the critical factors to consider:
The visual resemblance to the Submariner is the primary draw for most buyers. Key design elements to consider include:
- Overall Shape: Does it capture the classic Submariner case shape?
- Dial and Hands: Are the indices, hands (Mercedes hour hand, sword minute hand, lollipop seconds hand), and dial layout faithful to the original, while still offering a unique touch?
- Bezel: Does it have a unidirectional rotating bezel with a ceramic or aluminum insert and legible markings? A 120-click bezel generally feels more premium.
- Bracelet: Is the bracelet comfortable and well-made? Consider the clasp, solid end links, and overall finishing.
- Crystal: A sapphire crystal is a must-have for scratch resistance and clarity.
The movement is the engine that powers the watch and significantly impacts its reliability and accuracy. Common movements found in Submariner homages include:
- Japanese Movements (Seiko/Miyota): Known for their reliability and affordability. The Seiko NH35 and Miyota 8215 are popular choices. These movements are generally automatic and offer hacking (the seconds hand stops when the crown is pulled out) and hand-winding capabilities.
- Swiss Movements (ETA/Sellita): Offer higher accuracy and refinement but come at a higher price. The ETA 2824-2 and Sellita SW200-1 are common options and considered workhorses.
- Chinese Movements (Sea-Gull/PT5000): Offer good value for money. The Sea-Gull ST2130 and PT5000 offer similar performance to the ETA 2824-2 at a lower cost. The PT5000 has gained popularity for its improved accuracy and robustness.
Consider your budget and desired level of accuracy when choosing a movement.
High-quality materials and construction are crucial for longevity and a premium feel. Look for:
- Case Material: 316L stainless steel is the industry standard for its corrosion resistance and durability.
- Water Resistance: A true dive watch should have a water resistance of at least 200 meters (20 ATM). Make sure the watch has a screw-down crown and case back to ensure water resistance.
- Finishing: Pay attention to the finishing of the case, bracelet, and dial. Look for even brushing, polished chamfers, and crisp details.
The beauty of a Submariner homage is that it offers a similar aesthetic at a much lower price. Consider the overall value proposition: are you getting a well-built watch with a reliable movement and good materials for the price?
Based on the criteria above, here are some of the best Submariner homage watches available in 2024, categorized by price range:
- Invicta Pro Diver 8926OB: A popular entry-level option, often cited as the quintessential affordable Submariner homage. Powered by a Seiko NH35 movement, offering reliable performance. The finishing is basic, but it's hard to beat the value at this price point. (Source: Watchuseek forums - numerous threads discussing this model).
- Pagani Design PD-1661: A consistently well-regarded homage, often praised for its ceramic bezel, sapphire crystal, and Seiko NH35 movement. Offers excellent value and a more refined feel than the Invicta.
- San Martin SN008: A well-built option with good finishing and a reliable movement, often featuring the Seiko NH35 or Miyota 8215. San Martin is known for its attention to detail and quality control.
- Steinhart Ocean One: A highly respected Submariner homage known for its excellent build quality, Swiss movement (ETA 2824-2 or Sellita SW200-1), and attention to detail. Offers a premium feel and excellent accuracy. (Source: Steinhart Watches official website).
- Lorier Neptune: Features a vintage-inspired design with a domed acrylic crystal and a Miyota 90S5 movement. Lorier is praised for its unique aesthetic and excellent customer service.
- Tisell Submersible: Often features a high-quality Miyota 9015 movement and a well-finished case and bracelet. Tisell is known for its exceptional value and attention to detail.
- Christopher Ward C60 Trident Pro 300: While not a direct homage, the C60 Trident Pro offers a similar aesthetic with its own distinct design elements. Powered by a Sellita SW200-1 movement and features excellent build quality and finishing. (Source: Christopher Ward official website).
- Squale 1545: A Swiss-made dive watch with a classic Submariner-inspired design and a robust construction. Powered by a Sellita SW200-1 movement and features excellent water resistance. (Source: Squale official website). Squale has a long history of making dive watches and supplying components to other brands.
Before making a purchase, consider these factors to ensure you choose the right watch for your needs:
- Wrist Size: Make sure the watch case size (typically 40-42mm for Submariner homages) is appropriate for your wrist.
- Style Preference: Do you prefer a vintage-inspired look or a more modern design?
- Budget: Determine your budget and stick to it.
- Movement Preference: Do you prioritize accuracy or value?
- Water Resistance Needs: Consider how you plan to use the watch and choose a water resistance rating accordingly.
- Read Reviews: Research the watch you're considering and read reviews from other owners.
- Warranty and Customer Service: Check the warranty and customer service reputation of the brand.
To keep your Submariner homage in good condition, follow these maintenance tips:
- Regular Cleaning: Clean the watch case and bracelet regularly with a soft cloth and mild soap and water.
- Avoid Extreme Temperatures: Avoid exposing the watch to extreme temperatures or direct sunlight for extended periods.
- Service the Movement: Have the movement serviced every 3-5 years to ensure optimal performance.
- Check the Water Resistance: Have the water resistance checked periodically, especially if you frequently wear the watch in water.
- Store Properly: Store the watch in a cool, dry place when not in use.
